Chapter 4 - What Happened on County Road 19
Patricia did not give Michael the letter.
Instead she put it back in the box.
“Mom.”
“No.”
“You can't keep doing this.”
“I can keep one thing.”
“Why?”
“Because once you read it, you won't see her the same way.”
Michael folded his arms.
“I don't see her at all.”
“Exactly.”
Patricia shut the box.
“For forty-five years I've been angry enough for both of us. I don't need you inheriting it.”
“That isn't your decision.”
“Yes, it is.”
She stood.
Michael stayed seated.
“What did she do?”
Patricia looked tired.
“You know enough.”
“No. I know you took a criminal conviction, changed identities with your twin, and lost contact with her. That's not enough. That's insanity.”
“It was 1981.”
“That doesn't make it sane.”
“No. It makes it understandable.”
Michael waited.
Patricia looked through the window.
Snow had begun falling lightly outside.
“Raymond drove that night,” she said.
Michael said nothing.
“He was drunk. Susan knew it. She got into the car anyway.”
“Who died?”
“A boy named Daniel Price. Nineteen years old.”
“A passenger?”
“No.”
Patricia's eyes remained on the window.
“He was walking along the shoulder.”
Michael felt something sink inside him.
“They hit a pedestrian.”
“Yes.”
“And left.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Raymond panicked.”
“And Susan?”
“She panicked too.”
Michael shook his head.
“Then why did you confess?”
Patricia finally turned.
“Because Susan was pregnant.”
Michael stared at her.
“What?”
“She found out three days before the accident.”
“Raymond's?”
“Yes.”
Michael leaned back.
“Grandpa knew?”
“Not yet.”
“But Grandma did?”
“After the accident.”
Michael began seeing the outline.
A twenty-one-year-old daughter.
Pregnant by a married man.
A fatal hit-and-run.
A conservative family in 1981.
Still not enough.
“So your mother asked you to confess.”
“She asked me to say I'd been with Raymond.”
“Why would police believe you were Susan?”
“They didn't know us well. Susan and I looked almost identical. Raymond had disappeared.”
“You lied.”
“Yes.”
“Under oath?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
Patricia stared at him.
“Because my father said Susan would lose the baby if she went to jail.”
Michael was quiet.
“Would she have?”
“I don't know.”
“But you believed it.”
“I was twenty-one.”
Patricia's voice cracked slightly.
“And I believed my parents knew what adults were supposed to do.”
That sentence hurt more than Michael expected.
“What happened to the baby?”
Patricia looked down.
“She miscarried six weeks later.”
Michael closed his eyes.
“And you were still facing charges.”
“Yes.”
“Why didn't Susan come forward then?”
“Because by then everyone was trapped.”
Michael understood that part immediately.
Lies became expensive with age.
Once a family mortgaged itself to one, truth no longer felt like honesty.
It felt like foreclosure.
“Raymond?”
“Arrested in Arizona three months later.”
“He told police Susan was in the car?”
“Yes.”
“So why weren't you cleared?”
Patricia smiled bitterly.
“Because everyone agreed Susan had been there.”
Michael saw it.
“You were pretending to be Susan.”
“Yes.”
“And you admitted helping cover it up.”
“Yes.”
“He couldn't prove which twin.”
“No.”
“What happened to Susan?”
“My parents sent her to stay with an aunt.”
“And the identities?”
Patricia sat again.
“When I came out, nobody wanted to hire Susan Mercer.”
“You.”
“Yes.”
“My mother had an idea.”
“A terrible one.”
“Yes.”
“Susan had no conviction attached to Patricia Mercer.”
“Yes.”
“So you switched.”
“For three years.”
Michael rubbed his forehead.
“She abandoned you in her identity.”
Patricia didn't answer.
“She did.”
“She was scared.”
“She left.”
“Both can be true.”
Michael looked at his mother.
That was the first moment he understood how complicated her anger really was.
She did not hate Susan.
That would have been easier.
She still protected her.
Even now.
Michael spent the next week investigating quietly.
He found Daniel Price's obituary.
Nineteen.
Community college student.
Worked weekends at a hardware store.
Survived by parents and a younger sister.
Michael stared at the photograph for a long time.
The family secret had a victim.
That mattered.
He also discovered Raymond Bell had died in 2008.
Susan was harder.
But attorneys learned people left trails even when they wanted to disappear.
Property records led to California.
Marriage records led to Susan Elaine Park.
Then Patricia Anne Park.
Then a divorce.
Michael eventually found an address in Monterey County.
He stared at it.
Then called.
A woman answered.
“Hello?”
Michael knew immediately.
The voice.
Older than Patricia's.
But frighteningly similar.
“Is this Susan Mercer?”
Silence.
Then:
“Who is this?”
“My name is Michael Carter.”
The silence changed.
Not confusion.
Recognition.
“Oh,” the woman said.
Michael's grip tightened around his phone.
“So she finally told you.”
“No.”
“Then how did you find me?”
“I'm an attorney.”
Susan gave a short laugh.
“Patricia always did raise an irritatingly capable boy.”
Michael's anger arrived instantly.
“You don't get to talk about her like you've been part of our lives.”
Susan said nothing.
“You left her with your name.”
“I know.”
“She went to jail for you.”
“I know.”
“She built her entire adult life inside the mess you left behind.”
“I know.”
Michael stood and paced.
“You keep saying that.”
“What would you prefer?”
“I'd prefer an explanation.”
“Your mother has one.”
“She won't give me all of it.”
“Then neither will I.”
“Why?”
Susan's voice hardened.
“Because if Patricia still believes some things are hers to keep, I won't steal those too.”
That stopped him.
Michael returned to his desk.
“Come to Columbus.”
“No.”
“Why?”
“Because I promised myself I wouldn't.”
“That is not an answer.”
“It is when you're seventy miles from the nearest person who still remembers what a coward you were.”
“You're sixty-six.”
“I know how old I am.”
“Then stop acting like you're twenty-one.”
Susan went silent.
Michael immediately knew he had reached her.
He pressed.
“My daughter found this.”
“Your daughter?”
“Lily. She's eight.”
Susan exhaled.
“I know who Lily is.”
Michael froze.
“How?”
“Patricia sends Christmas cards.”
Michael sat.
“She sends you cards?”
“Every year.”
“Why?”
Susan's voice became very small.
“You'll have to ask her.”
The call ended soon after.
Michael drove directly to Patricia's house.
He found his mother in the backyard taking down a summer wind chime she had forgotten before winter.
“You send her Christmas cards.”
Patricia stopped.
Michael stood on the patio.
“Every year.”
She removed the wind chime.
“Yes.”
“You said she hadn't spoken to you in eleven years.”
“She hasn't.”
“But you write to her.”
“One card.”
“Why?”
Patricia looked at him as though the answer should be obvious.
“Because she's my sister.”
That was when Michael finally became angry in a way he could not control.
“She ruined your life!”
Patricia flinched.
“No.”
“She let you go to jail.”
“I chose that.”
“She left you with her identity.”
“Yes.”
“She disappeared.”
“Yes.”
“And you still send her pictures of us?”
Patricia stepped closer.
“Do not confuse forgiveness with forgetting.”
“Did you forgive her?”
Patricia looked toward the bare trees.
“No.”
“Then why?”
“Because I wanted her to know my life did not end where she left it.”
Michael had no answer.
Patricia walked past him.
At the back door she said, “You called her, didn't you?”
“Yes.”
“Is she alive?”
Michael stared.
Patricia's hand remained on the doorknob.
She truly did not know.
“Yes.”
Patricia closed her eyes.
For several seconds she did not move.
Then she whispered:
May you like
“Good.”
---
